How long does peanut butter last, opened or unopened?
Quick answer
- In the fridge
- Opened, regular or natural: 3–4 months, never past the best-if-used-by date · Unopened natural: 12 months from purchase or the jar's date, whichever comes first
- In the pantry
- Opened, regular (no-stir): 2–3 months · Unopened, regular: 6–9 months from purchase · Never past the best-if-used-by date · Natural: refrigerate once opened
Sources: USDA FoodKeeper, USDA FSIS: Molds on Food: Are They Dangerous?, USDA FSIS: Food Product Dating, FDA standard of identity: 21 CFR 164.150 Peanut butter, USDA AMS: United States Standards for Grades of Peanut Butter, North Dakota State University Extension: Food Storage Guide (FN579), University of Missouri Extension: Can-Do Recipes: Peanut Butter (N688), Colorado State University Extension: How to Use Peanut Butter, Illinois Extension: Nuts need food safety too · Last reviewed October 30, 2026
An opened jar of regular peanut butter keeps 2–3 months in the pantry and 3–4 months in the fridge, according to USDA FoodKeeper, and neither time should run past the best-if-used-by date on the jar. For unopened jars, FoodKeeper's entry for stabilized peanut butter gives 6–9 months from purchase, while its general commercial entry and North Dakota State University (NDSU) Extension allow 6–24 months, so let the printed date decide. Natural peanut butter appears in FoodKeeper only as a refrigerated food: 12 months unopened from purchase or until the jar's date, whichever comes first, and 3–4 months once opened, again within that date.
How to store peanut butter
Peanut butter's weak point is its oil. Illinois Extension notes that the fat in nuts and nut butters turns rancid over time, and that no-stir versions keep their oil from separating by adding fats, sugar or other ingredients. That regular kind can be kept in a cool, dark cupboard away from appliances that give off heat, as University of Missouri Extension and NDSU advise, though NDSU notes it keeps longer in the fridge. Natural peanut butter, just ground peanuts and maybe salt, has nothing holding its oil, so it rises to the top. Once opened, it belongs in the fridge, NDSU says, and Colorado State University Extension adds that the cold keeps the oil from separating again.
- An unopened jar of regular peanut butter needs no fridge, NDSU says, though it keeps longer there. If you stock up, write the purchase date on each jar and open the oldest first, the rotation rule NDSU gives for cupboard foods.
- The first time you open natural peanut butter, stir the oil layer back into the paste until it's smooth, and only then put the jar in the fridge. Missouri Extension advises stirring well before refrigerating and again before each use.
- An opened regular jar can stay in the pantry for a few months, Colorado State says, and is best moved to the fridge after that to extend its shelf life, never past the best-if-used-by date.
- Twist the lid shut as soon as you've taken what you need; Missouri Extension says air and bacteria getting in can affect the jar's freshness. Reach in with a clean, dry knife every time, too: USDA FSIS counts peanut butter among the foods at high risk for mold because it's processed without preservatives.
- Mark the opening date on the lid. The months on this page count from that day, and the best-if-used-by date still comes first.
- Chilled peanut butter is firmer and harder to spread, Missouri Extension notes. Spoon a portion onto your plate to soften instead of leaving the whole jar out on the counter.
Signs it has gone bad
- An older jar with no mold needs a sniff and a small taste. USDA's grading rules hold good peanut butter to the flavor and aroma of freshly roasted, freshly ground peanuts, free from staleness and rancidity; Illinois Extension notes that rancid fat shows up as an off taste, and NDSU that food kept beyond its recommended time or date may change in color and flavor. If yours tastes or smells stale or rancid, throw it out.
- Mold of any color on the surface, around the rim or under the lid. Throw the whole jar away rather than scraping off the spot and eating the rest. When in doubt, throw it out.
- Not spoilage: a layer of oil on natural peanut butter. Colorado State calls the separation normal; stir the oil back in before use.
- Not spoilage either: a stiff, hard-to-spread texture after a spell in the fridge, which Missouri Extension notes comes with refrigerating it.
Frequently asked questions
Should peanut butter go in the fridge or the pantry?
It depends on the type: regular no-stir peanut butter is fine in the pantry unopened, and for a few months after opening (Colorado State) within the best-if-used-by date, though cold makes it last longer, while natural peanut butter belongs in the fridge once it's open. Whatever the type, follow the storage directions on the jar, as Illinois Extension advises.
Can you eat peanut butter past its best-if-used-by date?
USDA FSIS says a best-if-used-by date shows when a product will be at its best flavor or quality; it is not a purchase or safety date. An unopened jar past it therefore calls for a check rather than an automatic toss: look for mold first and throw the jar out if you see any, without sniffing it; otherwise smell it and taste a little, and throw it out if it's stale or rancid. An opened jar shouldn't be kept past the date in the first place.
Why does natural peanut butter separate when regular doesn't?
USDA's grade standards sort peanut butter into two types: stabilized, made with a process or added ingredient designed to prevent oil separation, and nonstabilized, made without one. Under the FDA standard of identity, any oil used as a stabilizer must be hydrogenated. The ingredient list tells you which one you have: peanuts and maybe salt alone means natural.
Can peanut butter be frozen?
It's not a good idea. University of Missouri Extension says peanut butter doesn't freeze well and can turn grainy, which hurts its texture and flavor, and USDA FoodKeeper lists no freezer time for it. The fridge is the better way to stretch an opened jar.
Can peanut butter grow mold?
Yes. The FDA standard of identity doesn't allow chemical preservatives in peanut butter, and USDA FSIS, noting that foods processed without preservatives are at high risk for mold, lists it with nuts and legumes among the foods to discard rather than trim once mold appears. Throw out the jar at the first fuzzy or colored spot.
Related foods
Baking Powder
In the pantry: Unopened: 6–18 months from purchase, up to the best-if-used-by date · Opened, lid on tight: 3–6 months, not past that date · After that: test it before bakingBay Leaves
In the pantry: Dried, unopened jar: 1–2 years from purchase (general dried-herb figure), up to its best-if-used-by date · Opened: about 6 months for best quality (UF/IFAS, herbs and spices in general), not past that date · Home-dried: about 1 year (Penn State, most dried herbs)Chickpeas
In the pantry: Dried: 1–2 years from purchase, 1 year once the bag is open (USDA's figure for dried beans) · Unopened can: until its best-if-used-by dateChips
In the pantry: Unopened: until the best-if-used-by date (USDA: about 2 months from purchase) · Opened, clipped shut: 1–2 weeksCrackers
In the pantry: Unopened: up to 8 months from purchase, not past the best-if-used-by date · Opened: about 1 month, not past that date · Graham or animal crackers, unopened: 6–9 months from purchase, not past the dateDates
In the pantry: Up to 2 months from purchase, not past the date on the pack (USDA FoodKeeper) · UC Davis, commercial storage after harvest at 21°C (70°F) and 70–75% humidity: semi-soft dates about 1 month, soft ones such as Medjool about half that